Oh Mary: What the Critics Are Saying

Have you ever wondered what the final days of Mary Todd Lincoln might look like if they were reimagined through a lens of cabaret and comedy? Oh, Mary! is not just another historical play; it's a bold theatrical experience that dares to reimagine one of America’s most iconic first ladies as a cabaret-loving alcoholic who finds herself trapped in an unhappy marriage with Abraham Lincoln. This Broadway production has taken audiences by storm since its premiere in 2024, offering a fresh perspective on history with its sharp wit and outrageous humor.

Created by Cole Escola, a comedian known for his irreverent style, Oh, Mary! premiered Off-Broadway at the Lucille Lortel Theatre before making its way to the Great White Way. The show stars Betty Gilpin as Mary Todd Lincoln, delivering a performance that critics have hailed as both hilarious and heart-wrenching. The narrative unfolds during the weeks leading up to President Lincoln’s assassination, presenting a fictionalized version of events where Mary seeks solace in song and drink while grappling with her personal demons. It’s a tale filled with campy humor, unexpected twists, and a stellar cast that brings this surreal story to life.

The limited engagement of Oh, Mary! on Broadway has been met with rave reviews from both critics and theatergoers alike. Critics praise the play for its fearless approach to tackling historical figures with unapologetic humor. In one review, Time Out described it as “the funniest Broadway play in years,” highlighting Cole Escola’s portrayal of Mary Todd Lincoln as a boozy and vicious cabaret singer. The play blends dark comedy with poignant moments, creating a balance that keeps audiences engaged throughout its runtime.

Directed by Sam Pinkleton, Oh, Mary! embraces what its creators call “deep stupidity.” While some may view this self-deprecating label as a joke, it speaks volumes about the show’s willingness to push boundaries and challenge conventional storytelling. The dialogue crackles with clever wordplay, and the staging incorporates elements of drag culture, further cementing its place within contemporary theater. For those familiar with Escola’s work, the themes explored in Oh, Mary! come as no surprise—his signature blend of absurdity and authenticity shines brightly here.

Tickets for Oh, Mary! are available online or through a digital lottery system, ensuring fans have multiple opportunities to secure seats. The production runs until June 28, 2025, giving theater enthusiasts ample time to catch this must-see spectacle at the Lyceum Theatre in New York City. As part of its marketing strategy, the show encourages audience interaction via social media platforms, inviting patrons to share their experiences using specific hashtags. This digital engagement adds another layer to the overall experience, fostering a sense of community among fans.

One cannot discuss Oh, Mary! without acknowledging its cultural significance. By reimagining Mary Todd Lincoln as a queer icon, the play challenges traditional narratives surrounding gender and sexuality. Its depiction of Abraham Lincoln as a closeted gay man raises questions about historical interpretations and invites viewers to reconsider established truths. Such bold choices resonate deeply with modern audiences, who increasingly seek out art forms that reflect diverse perspectives.

In addition to its thematic innovations, Oh, Mary! boasts a remarkable technical execution. The set design transports audiences into a world where past and present collide, featuring vibrant colors and intricate details that evoke the spirit of cabaret. Costumes designed by Emily Rebholz enhance the visual impact, capturing the essence of each character while maintaining a playful edge. Lighting effects orchestrated by Jason Lyons add drama and depth, enhancing key moments throughout the performance.

While the play primarily focuses on Mary Todd Lincoln, supporting characters contribute significantly to its success. Each actor brings unique qualities to their role, contributing to the ensemble dynamic that makes Oh, Mary! so captivating. Together, they create a tapestry of emotions ranging from laughter to sorrow, reminding us why live theater remains an essential form of artistic expression.

For anyone interested in exploring how comedy can illuminate complex subjects, Oh, Mary! serves as a masterclass. It demonstrates that even the most serious topics can be addressed with levity when approached creatively. Through its exploration of identity, relationships, and societal norms, the play offers insights relevant to today’s world. Whether you’re a history buff, a fan of comedy, or simply looking for something different, this production promises an unforgettable evening.

As we reflect on the legacy of Oh, Mary!, it becomes clear that its influence extends beyond the stage. By merging historical context with modern sensibilities, the play inspires conversations about representation, creativity, and the power of storytelling. Its ability to entertain while provoking thought ensures its status as one of the standout productions of recent years. So, whether you choose to see it live or follow its journey digitally, don’t miss out on experiencing this extraordinary piece of theater.